In this FAQ series, we will try to answer questions that will hopefully help us become more biblically informed and better equipped to live out our faith in community. To submit and vote on questions you would like to see answered on the blog by our pastors, click here. To see other FAQ Friday posts, click here.
This week, David Allston, who is over our singles ministry, answered this week’s question from George in Greenville:
We see in a few places of the New Testament leaders ultimately kicking sinners out. Where is the line between the idea: We are all broken and can’t help to sin and living holy (With Hebrews 10:26-39 in mind)?
In order to answer this question, we must begin by talking about the tension we experience as men and women seeking to live for God’s glory in spite of the indwelling sin that affects us all. When God created the world, He made everything perfect. Adam and Eve were sinless and enjoyed uninhibited communion with the Creator. However, when they chose to disobey God and eat the fruit from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil, sin entered the world and spiritual death came upon us all. Romans 5 tells us that through Adam, sin entered the world and that in him, we are all dead in sin. We are also called enemies of God (Ephesians 2). Our sin nature is opposed to God and as long as we live on this earth, this nature will war against God. This is why Paul can say in Romans 7, that he does not do the things he wants to do and that he does the things he does not want to do. There is a war going on inside of each one of us. Our “flesh” or sin nature means that until we are taken to be with God in Paradise, we will struggle.
This leads us to some tension when we see Paul calling believers in places like Corinth “saints,” which means “holy ones.” How can Paul call these people “holy” when they are filled with sin? Romans 6 tells us that we died with Christ and so we are no longer slaves to sin, but have been freed from its power. We now live in freedom under God’s grace. We know that we are saved by faith alone through grace alone, which means that our righteousness comes from Christ alone. We are called “holy” because when the Father looks at His children, all He sees is the perfect work of His Son, Christ Jesus. Every single one of our sins has been covered by Christ’s blood and we will never have to pay the penalty we deserve. Our standing as “saints” is not of our own doing, but is a free gift from God.
The holy life that we are called to live can only be lived out through the power of the Holy Spirit...
The Gospel tells us that we have moved from being God’s enemies to being His children. The holy life that we are called to live can only be lived out through the power of the Holy Spirit who regenerated us and opened our eyes to see the truth in the first place. It is the Holy Spirit who brings about the change in us. Holy living does not happen from the outside in, but from the inside out as we lay down our lives and submit to the Spirit’s working in our hearts. Our motivation for following God’s commandments to us comes from our love for Him. Love for our Savior and His glory is what drives us to live holy lives.
Church discipline is the process for removing an unrepentant believer that we see prescribed in Scripture. The examples we see in Hebrews 10, 1 Corinthians 5, and Matthew 18 deal with one who claims to be a believer and yet refuses to obey God and turn from their sin. This is not describing one who is struggling to turn from sin and who desires to submit to the will of God. Rather it is describing one who believes that they are free to go on sinning while remaining in right relationship with the Father. Despite the clear commands of Scripture, these people go right on sinning without any remorse or effort to turn from sin. They reveal that they have no love for the One who gave everything for them. The command to the church is to put these men and women out of the Body.
The motivation, the method, and desired result for expelling someone from the body are often misunderstood.
The motivation, the method, and desired result for expelling someone from the body are often misunderstood. The motivation is to protect the body and to preserve the body as well as to call the sinner to turn from his sin and come back to God. In Matthew 18 Jesus gives the method for correcting a wayward believer.
If another believer sins against you, go privately and point out the offense. If the other person listens and confesses it, you have won that person back. But if you are unsuccessful, take one or two others with you and go back again, so that everything you say may be confirmed by two or three witnesses. If the person still refuses to listen, take your case to the church. Then if he or she won’t accept the church’s decision, treat that person as a pagan or a corrupt tax collector.
This process takes time and the clear desire is to restore the offending person. Galatians 6 tells us that we should humbly and gently help people back to the right path. We are to plead with them to repent and turn from their sin and come to God. Our desire must never be to hurt them or do them damage. We must remember that our sin against God is far greater than any sin they may have committed against us. This understanding will humble us allow us to patiently call sinners to repent. When we have come to the end of the process and the offending party resolutely refuses to repent, we are commanded to put them out. The sorrow over sin is clear in this process. When these people are put out, our hope remains that they will repent and come back. We see this in exemplified Scripture. Even the man who was expelled in 1 Corinthians 5 is restored to the body in 2 Corinthians 2. We see that love for the sinner is the motivation for correction and discipline.
Far too often we have seen this process carried out in hurtful and even wicked ways. As a result, when we think about expelling a sinner from the body, our connotations are primarily negative. A right understanding of our standing before God and our call to love others allows us to carry out God’s commands in a holy, loving way. At Grace Church, our desire is to go through the process of church discipline motivated by love and a desire to restore the sinner, rather than by a desire to punish and reject them. By the time someone is disciplined by the church, they have been through a lengthy process with community group leaders, pastors, and elders without any willingness to turn from sin and repent. While we have disciplined people and removed them from our body, our desire for those who have been put out remains that they would repent and come back to God and be restored.











